The Hospitality Investor Sentiment Index has given up the gains it made in Q3, with investors entering the final quarter of the year in a more subdued mood amid concerns about growth, risk and the financing environment.
The overall Index score dropped by 8.5 points to 47.9, crossing below the 50 no-change mark after reaching 56.4 in Q3. This signals a return to deteriorating overall sentiment after the improvement recorded in the previous quarter.
That is not to say investors have fallen out of love with hospitality real estate, far from it. Long-term and leisure demand expectations are still improving, but at a slower rate than in Q3, suggesting that some of the optimism seen three months ago has lost momentum.
Revenue expectations remain positive, but growth momentum has faded markedly. The index score fell 11.7 points to 52.6, meaning investors still expect revenues to increase, but at a much slower rate than in Q3. This will be one to watch as we move into 2027.
The top line looks considerably healthier than profitability. Investors still expect revenue growth, but with profitability at 34.2 they also expect the bottom line to decline. Why might that be? The survey doesn't give us the answer, but continuing pressure from labour and energy costs offers one possible explanation. Global energy prices rose materially between Q3 and Q4, increasing costs for businesses and adding to inflationary pressure. The Bank of England has warned that higher energy prices will continue to feed into firms' energy bills.
One of the clearest signals from this quarter's results is the changing price of risk. Debt pricing reversed direction, with the index jumping from 46.4 in Q3 to 68.4 in Q4. In other words, investors moved from expecting debt margins to fall to expecting them to rise. Hurdle rates were already increasing and are now increasing at an even faster rate. At the same time, growth in the use of leverage stalled, while risk appetite moved from unchanged to declining.
It's not difficult to see why investors might have become more cautious. The interest-rate outlook hardened during Q4 as inflation remained stubborn. The Federal Reserve held rates at 3.75 per cent - 4 per cent in October, although two policymakers voted for another increase, while the Bank of England raised Bank Rate to 4% in November as higher energy prices fuelled renewed inflationary pressure. Since the survey closed, expectations of further US rate rises have strengthened further
Methodology
The Hospitality Investor Sentiment Index gauges the sentiment of equity investors active in the hospitality sector by polling their opinions on a quarterly basis across consumer demand and operational performance, the demand for and availability of stock, appetite for risk and the pricing of investment opportunities.
The key elements of the methodology are:
- A questionnaire answered by senior decision-makers who are members of our Investor Council, representing leading investment firms.
- Responses are based on whether confidence levels are "higher", "the same" or "lower" than the previous quarter.
- A diffusion index method is used to arrive at the index score. The resulting index values are bounded between 0 (all investors respond lower) and 100 (all investors respond higher), with a theoretical no-change mark at 50 (all investors respond "the same" or equal proportions respond higher and lower). Values above 50.0 indicate an increase and values below 50.0 indicate a decrease. The distance from the 50 no-change mark signals the implied rate of change in the variable. The further from 50.0, the greater the rate of change.
Example: A movement from 60.0 in Q1 to 55.0 in Q2 does not indicate deteriorating sentiment. Although the level of the index has fallen, it has remained above 50.0 in both quarters. The correct interpretation is that sentiment increased in both quarters, but the rate of increase was slower in Q2 than in Q1.