Hotel private equity: Why purchase price matters more than ever

Commercial building
Commercial buildings. (CHUNYIP WONG/Getty Images)

Hotel investors are finding opportunities, but only at the right price. Despite strong appetite from private equity, family offices and lenders, transactions remain constrained by a persistent gap between buyer and seller expectations.

And for buyers, this means that the entry price has grown in importance as one of the few things within their control. 

"The investment landscape now is as challenging as it's ever been," said Raoul Malhotra, founder and CEO of Orka Investments. “You can’t reliably underwrite rental, ADR or NOI growth as comfortably as you once could, so your purchase price is the one thing you have to get right from day one.”

Entry price

The Shepherd Mayfair Hotel in central London, which opened in October 2026, was acquired off market from distressed global hotel and casino operator Genting. The joint venture between Orka Investments and Bain Capital described it as a “once in a generation” opportunity to acquire a vacant freehold block in Mayfair with significant repositioning potential.

While the buyers did not publicly disclose the 2021 purchase price, Estates Gazette reported the transaction at £75-£80 million, substantially below the peak asking price of £120 million.

Bid ask gap

However, many deals fall at the first hurdle because of the bid ask gap.  Fire safety, cladding works and deferred maintenance create substantial liabilities for buyers, said Charles Scudamore, managing director, Hetherley, a UK hotel investor, operator, and asset manager.

"Often you don't get much further than the initial conversation or the due diligence process. We’ve seen so many under-invested assets, some with contracts to house asylum seekers. The sellers have made their money; they’ve had enough and they want out. Well, we’re not the guys to come in and pay your bills that you haven’t paid for the last 15 years.”

Hold periods

Private equity investors may underwrite three-to-five-year hold periods, but hotel repositioning often takes much longer to stabilise.

"I don't think we've ever seen a set of numbers that has stabilised in three years," said Scudamore. "You take a hotel, reset it, refurbish it and reposition it, and it takes a lot longer than three years to deliver a stabilised return."

Yet PE expectations remain for an IRR in the high teens. Family offices are increasingly active in the hotel sector, and they expect high returns too.

Malhotra commented: “The family office is probably more demanding and more aggressive on return requirements than a private equity fund is. There is more availability of capital from more sources, but it is growing more sophisticated and looking for higher returns.”

Lender appetite 

Lenders, meanwhile, continue to show strong appetite for hotels. Pierre-Edouard Vintrou, head of investment & development, Vertiq Hospitality Partners, said: “I worked on a deal recently where the appetite from the main banks to service a portfolio of UK hotels was incredible.” 

Second tier challenger banks are active too, offering loan-to-value ratios of up to 75 percent.

While high street banks are conducting deeper analysis and asking tougher questions than they did a decade ago, debt financing remains accessible for appropriately structured deals, said Scudamore: "The banks put you through a much more forensic process than they used to," he said. "That's not a bad thing.”

Operational expertise

Operational expertise is an essential driver of value creation; and organisation that are involved in investment, operations and asset management - like Orka, Vertiq, and Hetherley - have an advantage.

"You have to be deeply involved in the day-to-day operations of the hotels," said Scudamore. "Profitability is key because that ultimately delivers the underlying capital value. You've got to get into the weeds of operations."

Vintrou agreed: “We want to have operational control because that’s how we create value for our investors.”

Market position

Two or three years ago, a common value-add strategy was to flip an independent operation to a franchise, but now some of the franchise fees don’t make sense anymore, Vintrou said, especially when they are higher than brand fees. Choosing a brand, changing a brand, or creating an independent hotel are very much location and asset-specific decisions, he added.

Again, the Shepherd Mayfair provides a useful example. Malhotra at Orka Investments said the positioning of the hotel was based on what was possible, practical, with a keen eye on exit and investment liquidity.

“We bought the worst asset in Mayfair,” he joked. “It was a compromised asset with smaller room sizes that wasn’t going to fit with the brand standards of any five-star operator in Mayfair.”

Exit considerations

“Going into a complex redevelopment and having to satisfy Marriott or Accor’s brand standards was more of a nightmare than we needed,” he said. “From an exit liquidity standpoint, having a 25-year HMA with one of the major groups massively reduces your liquidity and we wanted to offer a flag-free, vacant possession product. It’s also freehold so we’re hoping it’s going to be as liquid as you can get,” he explained.

In terms of operations, the hotel is delivering a £500-a-night product in a £1,000-£1,500-a- night market, he said: “There isn't a brand that exists in that space. To sell 82 rooms in Mayfair at that price point, we didn't feel that we needed the Marriott Bonvoy system or the Accor Live Limitless system.”

Secondary recaps

Beyond operations and repositionings, are there further techniques to unlock value? Malhotra described Orka as “a classic joint venture common equity type investor.” He said: “One of the ways we've been finding liquidity and getting returns to our investors, despite the challenges, is looking at secondary recapitalisations.”

In these transactions, one investor in a joint venture sells their stake to a new investor, while the underlying asset remains unchanged.  The strategy allows investors to realise gains before a final exit, for instance three years into a five-year hold period, while incoming investors gain access to a partially de-risked asset further along its lifecycle.

The fundamentals

Vintrou said that Vertiq prefers partnership structures where it co-invests typically with Asian family offices or US PE firms, shares risk and earns most of its reward through performance. It is moving away from deals with institutional landlords seeking fixed lease income because those structures offer less alignment and less opportunity to create and share value.

Despite the growing sophistication of deal structures, financial engineering cannot compensate for a weak underlying investment, said Scudamore: "At the end of the day, the fundamentals of the hotel have to be solid. If you're falling back on: 'Let's financially engineer a return here', I think you're probably stuffed."

All quotes taken from the panel ‘Private equity outlook: Pricing risk in a slower transaction market’ at the Annual Hospitality Conference 2026 in Manchester. The panel was expertly moderated by Lewis Corby, head of UK hotel capital markets, Colliers.