What exactly is an owner buying when they put somebody else’s name above the hotel door? Brands argue there are many benefits including plugging an asset into a distribution network spanning millions of customers, providing access to a loyalty programme, offering sales and marketing infrastructure, lending credibility with lenders and buyers etc.
But the thing is, none of that comes free. As with all good things, these benefits come with a price.
In addition to paying a royalty for use of the brand, franchisees also contribute towards marketing, reservations and other central programmes. Wyndham’s 2025 annual report, for example, says its direct franchisees generally pay royalties of around 5 per cent of gross room revenue, alongside marketing and reservation fees of between 2 per cent to 4 per cent.
So as more owners now scrutinise costs more critically and hotel groups compete even harder for the same deals, it’s clear that having a recognisable name is no longer enough.
Dimitris Manikis, president EMEA at Wyndham Hotels & Resorts puts it clearly in a frank chat with Hospitality Investor: “Franchisees essentially ask one question: ‘What are you going to do for me today?’”
He adds: “They pay a cost, they pay the bills, it’s their business. So it’s about ‘What am I going to do to actually help them be successful?’”
Buying demand
The most obvious value derived from a flag is distribution. Looking at Marriott, Bonvoy finished 2025 with almost 271 million members, having added around 43 million during the year, with Bonvoy members accounting for 68 per cent of Marriott’s room nights. Meanwhile, Wyndham Rewards had more than 122 million enrolled members at the end of 2025, with members accounting for more than 37 per cent of check-ins globally and more than 53 per cent in the US.
David Orr, CEO of The Sirius Hotel Group operates on both sides of the divide, with Sirius owning and operating The Resident as an independent brand, while its former Sleeperz hotels were converted to Four Points Flex by Sheraton under a Marriott franchise. And he notes the value of the flag, particularly in geographies where the physical product itself can be hard to differentiate.
“The market is full of ubiquitous and perhaps arguably homogenous product,” he says, adding “you cannot add lots of services to differentiate yourself but what you can do with the culture that we have is adding that to the Marriott Bonvoy loyalty programme with all its global members. That’s the reasoning behind choosing them.”
Independence has value too
That is the argument for the flag at its most straightforward: taking an independently operated hotel and attaching it to a global customer-acquisition engine. But the conversation is different when the independent property can also generate demand on its own.
Despite the above, Orr is also bullish about what remaining independent can achieve, arguing that with The Resident, control over the experience and the hotel’s reputation effectively becomes the brand.
“With the independent approach, you’re completely in control of everything you do. Your reputation is entirely your own. You build it, live with it and nurture it,” he said, noting that while there are lots of merits with global brands, an independent’s reputation can be in itself one of the strongest forms of differentiation.
So while a brand can give an independent hotel access to customers it might struggle to reach itself, if an established independent already has strong direct demand, a differentiated proposition and a good reputation, the incremental benefit has to be weighed against the fees and restrictions attached to brand affiliation. Sirius shows that the answer can be different from one asset to another.
The big question
For David Anderson, president of Aimbridge EMEA, the test comes back to performance. When considering where value is being lost in a hotel, Anderson said one of the questions his team would ask is whether the property has the right brand at all or whether it even needs one.
If a major brand is missing from a particular market, that can create leverage for the owner.
“If there was no Marriott or no Hyatt or no Hilton in this market, well, they’d be really keen to come in. They may be willing to put key money in and help you finance any upgrades you need to do,” Anderson says to Hospitality Investor.
Wyndham notes that it may provide development advances to selected owners to help convert hotels, construct new properties or support other franchise expansion.
That financial support can be a big mover when considering the pros and cons of adding a brand, especially when the hotel in question needs significant capex spend.
But Anderson stresses that brand value must be visible in the numbers. Among the KPIs he considers important are revenue generation against the competitive set, the proportion of revenue reaching GOP, service scores and the operator’s ability to turn loyalty membership into repeat demand.
For owners, he said, the question should be: “Are we winning more of the market than our competitors?”
If the answer is no, the fact that the hotel carries a globally recognised flag doesn’t mean much.
Demanding more
And brands are facing more pressure to demonstrate that value. Timothy Walton, senior vice president, Western Europe, international hotel development at Marriott notes competition between hotel groups has intensified significantly over the past five years as companies have added more brands and vie more intensely for the same opportunities.
As a response, owners have started asking for more competitive commercial terms.
“We are being asked to be more flexible in terms of our commercial structure,” Walton says.
And as Marriott may carry a price premium in some circumstances, part of his team’s role is convincing owners that the return warrants that premium.
“To some extent, you get what you pay for,” he notes.
Looking at Marriott’s European growth, Walton said a large majority of deals signed had been franchise agreements instead of management contracts as more owners want the power of a brand while keeping more control over operation of the underlying asset.
At the end of 2025, Marriott had 7,644 franchised, licensed or otherwise affiliated properties, compared with 1,966 managed hotels and just 51 owned or leased properties. With Wyndham, 95 per cent of its business is franchise-led, with the company reporting more than 6,200 franchisees globally at the end of 2025 and signing a record 870 franchise contracts during the year.
That growth gives franchisors scale and increases the burden to continue to prove that scale is useful to each individual owner.
“In the franchise world, you need to keep on being on your toes all the time because you need to keep on enhancing value and confirming your value,” Manikis says, noting that technology, distribution and marketing are among the things the group must continue investing in on behalf of owners.
Doing the maths
All in all, measuring the return on a hotel flag is not as simple as subtracting the franchise fee from the revenue delivered through the brand’s website.
An owner is buying a bundle which includes consumer recognition, access to loyalty members, global teams and infrastructure as well as lender/investor confidence in the asset and potentially the value of the asset itself.
On the other hand, there are royalty and system fees, the cost of complying with brand standards and potentially substantial property improvement requirements as well as the somewhat nebulous and harder to quantify cost of giving up some flexibility over how the hotel looks, operates and changes.
Turning to HVS for guidance, the consultancy stresses that there is no one-size-fits-all approach, with the appropriate operating model depending on factors including an owner’s objectives, market conditions and the characteristics of the property. Its 2025 U.S. Franchise Fee Guide also says owners and lenders need to weigh the benefits of brand affiliation against the total cost of the commitment while cautioning that fee comparisons alone cannot show the impact a particular brand will have on an individual hotel’s profitability.
That is why the answer can look different even within the same ownership group. At Sirius, Marriott's loyalty and distribution make sense for Four Points Flex but at The Resident, Orr believes direct reputation and independent control create greater value. For Aimbridge, the answer might be to introduce a flag where it can elevate an asset into a new competitor set but only if the operating performance supports the move.
Marriott's scale is tempting indeed but Walton admits that owners now have enough competing options to push brands harder on price and flexibility. And for Wyndham, a franchise only remains compelling if the company continues to answer Manikis' question: what are you doing for the owner today?
It seems the hotel flag has no fixed value. Its worth is the difference between what an asset - calculated on a case-by-case basis - can produce without it and what that same asset could produce with it, less the fees of course.