You may think that because all the space in your luxury hotel is being utilised, then there’s nothing left to optimise. But you could be wrong. Being occupied doesn’t necessarily mean it’s producing revenue to the best of its ability. A ballroom used only a handful of times a month or acres of gardens that guests simply walk through are all examples of real estate that isn’t working hard enough. And as pressure on expenditure continues to pile on, more people are asking if every square metre available is being put to its highest and best use.
More than just rooms
Nick Turner, chief operating officer of Luxury Hotel Management says that re-examination is central to the business model being developed around the Liberty Hotels & Resorts concept which is rethinking the use of hotel inventory in its properties. For example, a former meeting room could become a space for Pilates, yoga or another wellness use. This is as he expects revenue mix to be split roughly into thirds: rooms; food and beverage; and health, leisure and wellbeing i.e. a reduction of reliance predominantly on hotel stays.
Thomas Lamson, vice president development and PTS EMEA at The Ascott Limited says this trend is set to be even more pronounced. Asked how he expected Ascott's business to change over the next three years, his answer was: “There will be more and more non-room revenue.”
But that does not necessarily mean squeezing a till into every corner. Ascott's lyf brand gives an example of what it means to make hotel space productive. Alexandra Van Pelt, development director for Northern Europe, describes its public areas as deliberately “very activated”. The concept includes co-working space, a shared kitchen designed to encourage interaction, chill-out areas, fitness facilities and dedicated employees whose role includes activating the building and “bringing the outside in”.
A traditional hotel lobby may technically be occupied space but economically contribute very little aside from being the place check in takes place. However, lyf treats this sort of space as somewhere guests are encouraged to work, eat, meet and spend time.
Reading guests’ needs
When it comes to the underutilisation of space, Ina Plunien, senior vice president of hospitality at Cain says it also starts with the guest.
“Who are we selling hotel room spaces to? Who are they? How are they likely to use the spaces? And how do they want to feel?” she asked.
Only after that does the economics of each area of the asset come into play, with Plunien noting that Cain then applies what she describes as a continuous “highest and best use” assessment but also stressing that the highest and best use is not permanent.
“Hospitality is always evolving. Just because we found a highest and best use at one moment in time doesn't mean it will stay that way for ten or fifteen years,” she said.
That principle could sometimes mean decisions that seem counter intuitive. At Delano Miami Beach, Cain looked at a fourth floor containing some of the property's smallest and lowest-rated bedrooms. While the usual instinct would be to protect the keys, Plunien said the team instead questioned whether those rooms were the most valuable use of the space, particularly given its ambitions to draw more local customers into the hotel.
The bedrooms went, reducing room count but in their place came a members' restaurant and social space, lounge areas, a terrace and an additional pool, all of which increased the earning potential of the wider asset.
Thinking outside the box hotel
Meanwhile, for Ben Harper, CEO of Watergate Bay Hotel, Another Place and SeaSpace, the opportunity doesn’t end at the hotel’s back door, spotlighting the use of the real estate surrounding a property.
At Another Place, The Lake, shepherd huts and a treehouse were introduced into the grounds as alternative accommodation, alongside a Glasshouse capable of supporting additional F&B and other uses. At SeaSpace in Cornwall, the opportunity came from ten acres of surrounding land. A five-court padel facility was introduced using a partner, meaning the concept could add to the experience and commercial offer without the hotel funding all of the capex itself. Another use being added to the ground is an outdoor spa which includes a sauna, hot tub and cold plunge.
Harper described the opportunity simply as bringing the hotel's real estate “into play”.
However, experts note that not every quiet room is an invitation for change. Patrick Chiappetta, CEO of Altus Hospitality warns that hospitality is already operationally complex and that inserting additional concepts into the building only works if somebody knows how to operate them properly.
“You have to find someone who knows how to do the things that you're asking to be done,” he said. Otherwise, a hotel may technically produce more revenue while simultaneously adding enough labour and complexity to wipe out the benefit.
“All these great ideas are great,” Chiappetta said, but without the operational capability “you're just going to spend money” and see the extra cash disappear elsewhere in the P&L.
Cain itself has used specialist third-party operators where it believes they can create more value.
However, Chiappetta warns that third-party operation is not a magic wand.
“They need managing,” he said, stressing that outsourcing the operation does not outsource the owner's responsibility for determining whether the space is delivering what it was meant to.
And in some cases, if making a change doesn’t yield the desired effects, the best move might be just realising it doesn’t work and restrategising.
For example, at a hotel Plunien previously worked with, significant investment had gone into creating a destination bar. It did not become the destination envisioned and so the team looked at what the local market was asking for and saw demand for social events such as weddings and birthday parties. The space looked good, already contained a bar and had the infrastructure. So they changed what they were selling and the failed destination bar became event space.
So how do you know that a space is working? Plunien argues that the industry needs to move the discussion beyond revpar, and more towards metrics such as trevpar which measures total hotel operating revenue including rooms, F&B, spa, parking, leases and other revenues divided by available rooms.
In a nutshell, experts from across the spectrum of the industry are constantly rethinking the use of space against changing customer behaviour. Meeting rooms are becoming wellness studios, passive lobbies are being turned into social spaces and hotel grounds are turning into accommodation and leisure. Even bedrooms are no longer automatically sacred. The trick to success is always asking - and accurately answering - the question of whether every square metre is still doing the right job.